Renting a truck vs hiring junk removal in Pittsburgh

The short answer

Renting a pickup or box truck from U-Haul or any rental company and hauling junk yourself can make sense if you have strong helpers, a lot of material, a nearby facility that accepts it and a free day. It makes less sense when items are in a basement or up narrow stairs, when the load includes TVs or freon appliances, or when your time is limited. JunkRabbit's flat prices include the crew, carrying from any floor and disposal: a quarter truck is $241, a half truck $431 and a sofa $126.

What the rental price leaves out

A truck rental quote covers the truck. The real cost of a do-it-yourself haul includes several other lines. There is mileage and fuel, because Pittsburgh's hills, bridges and river crossings mean the route to a disposal facility is rarely direct. There is the gate fee at the facility, which each one sets for itself, and which can depend on weight or material. There may be extra charges for items like tires, mattresses or appliances, if the facility accepts them at all. There are moving blankets, straps and a hand truck if you do not own them. There is the time to pick up the truck, load it, drive to the facility, wait, unload and return the truck before the deadline. And there is the labor of at least two people for most of a day. Add all of that before comparing it with a flat price that includes the carrying and the disposal.

Driving a rental truck in Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh is not an easy place to drive a box truck you are not used to. The City has 446 bridges, 90 neighborhoods spread over ridges and hollows, steep streets, tunnels and tight turns. Many residential streets are narrow two-ways with cars parked on one side, and rowhouse blocks in Lawrenceville, Bloomfield, Polish Hill and the South Side Flats leave little room to stop. Hillside streets in Mt. Washington, Troy Hill and Beechview can be steep enough to make a loaded truck nervous on the way down. In winter, from December through March, ice adds risk. Parking a rental truck while you load can also be tricky, especially if your house is reached by public steps and the truck has to wait at the bottom. None of this is impossible, but it is worth weighing honestly if you have not driven a large truck before.

The loading is the hard part

Most junk is not sitting in the driveway. It is in the basement, the attic, a third-floor bedroom or a garage at the bottom of a steep drive. The City's median home dates to 1942, and older houses have narrow, steep stairs, low basement ceilings and tight doorways. Getting a sofa, a dresser, a washer or a dozen heavy boxes from there to a rental truck is the work that matters. It takes at least two people, good gloves and, for appliances, a hand truck with straps. On a hillside house reached by city steps, every item goes down every step by hand. Injuries during do-it-yourself moves are common, and they are usually backs and hands. With a flat-price pickup, the crew carries everything out from any floor with no stairs fee, and you do not lift anything. That difference is often worth more than the rental savings.

Where do you take it?

Once the truck is loaded, it has to go somewhere that will accept it. Facilities around the region set their own hours, gate rates and rules about residential loads, so call ahead before you drive. Some materials need separate stops. TVs and computers cannot go to a Pennsylvania landfill under the Covered Device Recycling Act, so they have to go to an electronics recycler, such as the City's e-waste partner, which charges fees by material and weight. Refrigerators, freezers and air conditioners need refrigerant recovered before disposal. Metal may be better taken to a scrap yard. Usable furniture could go to the Habitat for Humanity ReStore in Swissvale, which also offers free donation pickup on its own schedule. A single load can easily become three or four stops, each with its own hours and line, before the truck goes back.

A side-by-side comparison

For the do-it-yourself version of any of these, add the rental, mileage, fuel, gate fees, separate e-waste and appliance stops, and a day of labor for two or more people. Then decide which number you prefer. The flat prices above include carrying from any floor, loading and disposal.

When renting a truck still makes sense

Renting a truck is a good choice in some situations. If you are already renting one for a move and the junk is a small extra, adding a trip can be efficient. If the material is mostly heavy debris you are producing yourself during a long renovation, and you have a crew, a truck can work. If you already have helpers, the items are on the ground floor and there is a facility nearby that takes everything, the savings can be real. For everything else, especially basements, attics, hillside houses, TVs and freon appliances, a flat-price pickup is simpler. JunkRabbit works 7 days a week from 8am to midnight, with same-day pickup when you book by 4 PM, and you choose a 2-hour arrival window. Vetted, insured local haulers do the work, and the price is shown before you book.

Frequently asked questions