Junk removal vs dumpster rental in Pittsburgh

The short answer

Choose a dumpster when you have a long project that produces debris every day for weeks, a driveway or legal spot to put the container, and people to do the loading. Choose junk removal when the job is a one-time cleanout, when items are in a basement or upstairs, when there is nowhere to put a container, or when the load includes things a dumpster cannot take. JunkRabbit's truck tiers run from $241 for a quarter truck to $732 for a full truck, with the carrying and loading included.

The two models are different jobs

A dumpster rental and a junk removal pickup sound similar, but they are different services. With a dumpster, a container is dropped at your property for a rental period, you fill it yourself, and it is hauled away when you are done. The rental covers the container, the delivery and the pickup, usually with a weight allowance and rules about what can go inside. You provide all the labor. With junk removal, a crew comes at a scheduled time, carries everything out from wherever it is in the house, loads the truck and leaves. The price covers labor, loading and disposal together. So the real question is not which costs less on paper. It is whether you want to rent a container and do the carrying yourselves, or pay for a crew that does the carrying. In Pittsburgh, where so much junk lives in basements and up narrow stairs, the carrying is often most of the work.

Where would the dumpster go?

This is the first practical question in Pittsburgh, and in much of the City it has no easy answer. Many streets are narrow two-ways with one parked lane, and rowhouse blocks in Lawrenceville, Bloomfield, Polish Hill and the South Side Flats often have no driveways at all. Some houses have an alley behind them, but alleys are narrow and shared. On hillside streets in Mt. Washington, Troy Hill, Beechview and the South Side Slopes, the house may sit up a flight of public steps with no flat ground nearby. Placing a container on a City street raises questions about street rules, so check with the City before you order one. In the suburbs, the picture is easier. Houses in Bethel Park, Ross Township, Penn Hills or Cranberry often have driveways, though a heavy container can mark a driveway, and HOA rules in newer subdivisions may limit how long one can sit there.

Who carries it, and how far?

A dumpster solves the last step, from the driveway to the landfill. It does nothing for the first steps, from the basement to the driveway. In the City, where the median house was built in 1942, basements are nearly universal and stairs are steep and narrow. Carrying a dresser, a sofa or forty boxes up a cellar stair, out the door and over the side of a dumpster is hard work, and in winter it happens on icy steps. If you have friends or a contractor crew doing the work, that may be fine. If you do not, the labor is the real cost. Junk removal includes the carrying from any floor, with no stairs fee. For a basement cleanout in a rowhouse, that difference usually decides it. Many people who rent a dumpster for a cleanout end up spending a whole weekend loading it, and still have items left over at the end.

What a dumpster cannot take

Dumpster rentals come with rules about contents, and the details vary by provider, so read the rental agreement. Common restrictions follow the same logic as the City curb. TVs and computers are banned from Pennsylvania landfills under the Covered Device Recycling Act, so they generally cannot go into a container bound for one. Refrigerators, freezers and air conditioners hold refrigerant that must be recovered first. Tires, batteries, paint and chemicals are often restricted. Heavy materials such as concrete or brick may have their own rules because of weight limits. In a real Pittsburgh cleanout, those items show up constantly: the basement freezer, the old console TV, the snow tires and the paint cans. They have to go somewhere else. A junk removal pickup handles them in the same visit at flat prices, such as $164 for a fridge, $68 for a 42 to 65 inch TV, $87 for four tires and $30 for a gallon of paint.

Truck tiers for comparison

These prices include the crew, carrying from any floor, loading and disposal. A basement of mixed junk plus a fridge and a TV might be a half truck plus those two items: $431 + $164 + $68 = $663. When comparing with a dumpster quote, add the value of your own labor and the cost of disposing of the restricted items separately.

When each one wins

A dumpster usually wins for a full gut renovation lasting weeks, at a suburban house with a driveway, where a contractor crew produces debris daily and loads it as they go. It can also suit a roofing job or a large landscaping project. Junk removal usually wins for one-time cleanouts of basements, garages, estates and apartments; for any City house without a place to put a container; for jobs where the items are upstairs or downstairs; for loads with TVs, freezers, tires or paint; and for anything that has to happen today. Many renovations use both: a dumpster for daily debris, and a pickup at the end for the old appliances and the things the container could not take. JunkRabbit works 7 days a week from 8am to midnight, with same-day pickup when you book by 4 PM. Photos give you the flat price before booking, and it only changes if you approve.

Frequently asked questions